A Nutritionist’s Dilemma
As I continued going through the store picking up the rest of the ingredients, it was as if my inner conscience wouldn’t let me leave the store until I swamped the regular cream cheese for the light version. I just couldn’t shake that thought out of my head. Then, as I was grabbing for a tub of plain yogurt an idea struck me like a whirlwind. It was as if the heavens opened and the angels started singing, “Finally a cheesecake that I can feel good about eating!” I’ve always wanted to experiment making a cheesecake that was comparable to the infamous Kraft Kitchens OREO Mini Cheesecake recipe in both simplicity and taste. I decided that it would be the perfect day to try something new! I should probably mention the fact that I had been trying to look for healthier and lower fat versions of cheesecake for a long time, mostly because my dad is a diabetic and his favorite dessert is cheesecake. He’s usually quite good at limiting sweets but his weakness is cheesecake. As a result, whenever I bake cheesecake at home, I always make sure to make a few that contain less sugar just for him, but never really adjusted for the fat content of the cheesecake. The majority of recipes that I came across replaced some part of cream cheese with ricotta, cottage cheese, yogurt or even silken tofu!
4 Easy Steps to a Slim Alternative
Hence, when I was grabbing for the yogurt, the idea of making a yogurt based cheesecake just made sense. The yogurt would provide the perfect tang resembling the familiar taste in a cheesecake. So off I went to bake a yogurt cheesecake! I must admit that I’ve actually made the Kraft Kitchen’s OREO Mini Cheesecakes numerous times and have only received positive comments about them. With a recipe that only requires 4 ingredients and 3 steps, it is hard not to love it! So, having known the recipe by memory, I began using it as the basis for my own yogurt cheesecake recipe. Below is the recipe for my mini yogurt cheesecakes (click on the image to enlarge):
Small and Cute
I have a fetish for mini bite-sized foods because I think food is just sooooo cute and adorable when they are in their miniature versions! Plus, that way people can try a little bit of everything, which is what I love to do. I mean, don’t you ever find yourself in a situation where you want to try everything that is in front of you but you can’t because the portions are just too big, and it would be a waste of food if you can’t finish it all. Then, there are also the people who are watching their waistlines that you want to cater to. These mini cheesecake bites would be perfect because they are just the right size to satisfy a sweet tooth. Not to mention the fact that the lemon ginger cookies on the bottom really gives the cheesecake a little *punch* of flavour!
If you are like me, you are probably wondering exactly how much better these yogurt cheesecakes are from a nutritional stand-point. Well, lucky for you, I’ve created a comparison chart below:
Can you believe that even if you ate 4 of those bite-sized yogurt cheesecakes, you still would be saving approximately 90 calories and 11 g of fat, plus you would be consuming 10% more of your daily calcium requirement for the day! Quite impressive I must say!
I have a feeling that some of you who are reading this may be wondering why I didn’t think about using an artificial sweetener such as sucralose (aka. SPLENDA®) for a recipe intended for my dad and those that are diabetic. Well, for the record, I would like to say that I do not, I repeat, I DO NOT recommend nor believe in the consumption of artificial sweeteners of any kind. Even though Health Canada has approved and deemed artificial sweeteners such as aspartame, sucralose, soribitol, isomalt, lactitol, malitol, mannitol and xylitol as safe, I wouldn’t trust placing these chemicals into my body. Studies on the safety of these non-nutritive sweeteners have been controversial and because these non-nutritive sweeteners have only been around for a few decades, there hasn’t been enough time to assess the long-term effects of these substances.
In my yogurt cheesecake recipe I chose to use honey instead of granulated sugar because it provides a distinctive flavour that has a hint of floral sweetness that plain old sugar just doesn’t have. It is important to note that all sugar, whether the source is from fruits, honey, or molasses, is still sugar. Sure, honey may provide some antioxidant properties and blackstrap molasses may be a good source of iron, but in the end sugar is sugar.
What is GI
When I was formulating my yogurt cheesecake I wanted to tweak the classic Kraft Kitchen’s OREO Mini Cheesecake by finding a way to lower the amount of fat as well as increasing the amount of protein. It was important for me to find a way to lower the fat without increasing the amount of carbohydrates because I wanted to keep the glycemic index of the cheesecake as low as possible. So what exactly does glycemic index even mean? Well, glycemic index is a scale that ranks carbohydrate-rich foods by how much they raise blood glucose levels compared to a standard food (ie. white bread / glucose). Therefore, the lower the GI rating of a food, the less impact it will have on the rise in blood glucose levels. Factors that influence the glycemic index rating of food include cooking, food processing and the amount of fat, protein or acid present in the food. Cooking can increase the GI rating of food because the heat given off during the cooking process swells starch molecules and softens foods making it faster to digest. The same applies to highly process foods which are digested faster and thus have a higher GI rating. For example, pasta that is cooked al dente could have a GI rating of about 40, whereas overcooked spaghetti could have a GI rating of 70. Fat, protein and acid lowers the GI rating of food because they all delay the emptying of food from the stomach into the small intestine. This means that food is digested slower, and slower digestion means slower rise in blood glucose levels.
There’s Always Room for Dessert
This would mean that when planning meals, you should choose at least one low GI food per meal and try to exchange high GI foods for lower GI alternatives. An easy swap could be switching from a bowl of instant oatmeal (GI=70) for a bowl of old fashioned oatmeal (GI=49), or substituting a sandwich made with white bread (GI=70) for sourdough bread (GI=52). In the case of my yogurt cheesecake, it consists of a combination of yogurt, cream cheese, sugar and egg. Hence, the glycemic index of the entire cheesecake as a whole entity is actually surprisingly low, due to the high source of protein (4 bite sized cheesecake = 10g) present. To top things off, if the cheesecake was to be eaten after a well-balanced meal that consisted of ample amounts of vegetables, whole grains and protein then the bite-sized cheesecakes wouldn’t really have a dramatic impact on raising blood sugar levels. At the end of the day, moderation and balance is the key to healthy eating for everyone, not just people with diabetes.
Back to the Cheesecake
I’ve experimented with many different cookie bases and I can say for a fact that the PC Blue Menu 100 Calorie packet cookies have been the only cookie that has fit 100% perfectly into the mini muffin tins! Check out below for a review of products that I have tested out:
Let me know how you like the recipe and please share of your own more “healthy” cheesecake recipes! Just a word of caution, you must be prepared to resist the temptation to devour the mini cheesecakes before the minimum 3 hours of refrigeration is reached, because these will be quite delicate and soft when they come out of the oven. But don’t worry, they are definitely worth the wait!
My next cheesecake adventure includes:
• Using the PC Blue Menu cranberry orange or oatmeal chocolate chip cookie for the base
• Baking my own homemade cookie base
• Using maple syrup, agave syrup or stevia as the sweetener
Stay tuned for more sweet ideas.