Gluten is a composite of the proteins gliadin and glutenin. It is formed during the manipulation of flour with liquid (ie. Kneading and mixing). More development leads to a chewier product and less development yields tender baked good. Since gluten holds ingredients together and provides structure, then a binding agent needs to be added to serve as a gluten replacement.
Xanthan what?
Xanthan gum is a polysaccharide – a chain of complex carbohydrates produced during the fermentation of corn syrup by the bacterium Xanthomonas campestris. It has been long used as a thickener, emulsifier and stabilizer in the commercial production of foods ranging from ketchup to salad dressing and ice cream. This powdery substance has the ability to add lift and gluten-like elasticity to baked goods.
Eggy situation
Okay, now after all this research I had to roll up my sleeves and start baking! How bad could it be, right? I figured that for my first attempt, the safest option would be for me to take my good old trusted chocolate chip cookie recipe and replace the wheat flour with a Bob’s Gluten-Free all purpose mix. I then replaced the egg with the slimy goop of grounded flaxseed and water.
Verdict
The cookies turned out to be amazingly delicious and were comparable in every aspect to the original ones, with the exception of being slightly softer and more delicate in texture. My entire family loved it and my sister devoured almost ½ a dozen of them within 2 hours! It certainly felt good to be able to provide her a treat that she was actually able to eat.
Stay tuned for next weekend, when I try using my own homemade gluten-free flour mix blend using:
- 2 cups rice flour (ideally brown rice flour)
- 2/3 cup potato starch
- 1/3 cup tapioca flour
haha! were these what i tried?? :) they taste as yum as regular cookies! =)
ReplyDeleteawesome post!
ReplyDeleteI do have a couple questions though:
1) you were talking about "development" and how more development leads to chewier cookies. What exactly is "development"?
2) Is Xanthan gum healthy? if you didn't have to make cookies for your sister, would you still prefer using gluten?! What are some benefits?
Ah, gluten-free cookies. Because I'm testing out a gluten-free, dairy free diet for a month (due to health reasons that we won't get into), I will definitely give these a try...although, I'll have to substitute the chocolate chips for something else. Is gluten-free all purpose flour more expensive than regular all purpose flour?
ReplyDeleteGood questions Priscilla! Firstly, by "development" I was referring to the extent to which you manipulate the dough mixture. For example, if you were making muffins, if you overmix (ie. over develop) the dough than your muffins turn out really tough and hard.
ReplyDeleteIn regards to your second question, I first have to clarify for you that gluten is a protein that is found in grains such as wheat, barley and rye. If I had to choose between making a baked good using the conventional wheat flour or rice flour, I would have to choose wheat flour. This is just based on the fact that wheat flour is a common staple in my pantry. In addition, both xanthan gum & gluten-free all purpose flour are quite expensive.
For those who cannot eat dairy, I suggest substituting the chocolate chips with carob chips, which are most often dairy-free and can be found in most grocery and health food stores. Carob chips are made with carob powder and have an earthy, cocoa-like flavor that's more mellow than chocolate. Carob powder comes from the pod of the Mediterranean carob tree. The pod is seeded, then the fruit pulp is dried, roasted, and ground to a fine powder.
Alternatively, you could use a mixture of nuts and dried fruit. For example, almonds and dried cherries would be an excellent combination.
wow another way for me to eat a bit healthier while keeping me sweet tooth!
ReplyDeletethanks!
very interesting. i never would have thought about substituting ground up seeds with water for egg. that just seems so random but your picture showed me how similar in texture the two really are!
ReplyDeletethis post was definitely one of the best science classes i've been to! hahahah
you really seem like you know your material!
I haven't tried making my own GF flour blend but I used the blend from Bob's Red Mill (with the addition of xanthan gum) to make some some sugar cookies last winter. The cookie dough tasted pretty gross raw compared to dough made with all-purpose flour, but the cookies tasted delicious and just like their gluten-filled counterparts by the time they came out of the oven! I'm looking forward to reading about more of your adventures in desserts.
ReplyDeleteAmanda, I'm so excited you posted a recipe for gluten free cookies! I have Celiac Disease and therefore have to adhere to a gluten free diet and have not always had success with baking in the past, but its nice to know these cookies have been tested and had great results. Look forward to reading about your next baking adventures...!
ReplyDeleteI suckered my room mate into making these cookies (as I am not a baker myself), but she wasn't really sold on the egg substitute. Hopefully she'll change her mind very soon as we will get to taste these cookies in t-minus 7 minutes!
ReplyDeleteHi Amanda,
ReplyDeleteCookies turned out awesome, my neighbours couldn't tell the difference!
I followed your suggestion of using the egg substitute in banana bread as well, but I wasn't a big fan. Maybe I'm used to my Mom's banana bread or the fact that I'm not an avid baker - it just wasn't the same. It's not that I don't suggest this for other people, it just takes some getting used to, I guess. Thanks for the suggestion though.
Any more ideas? I love my desserts.